Bahadir Yildirim All articles
Creative Process

The Diner With No Yelp Page: Mining the Town You'd Rather Forget

Bahadir Yildirim
The Diner With No Yelp Page: Mining the Town You'd Rather Forget

Photo by Photo by Chad Nathan on Unsplash on Unsplash

There's a diner back home with no Yelp page, no website, and a handwritten sign by the register that says NO SEPARATE CHECKS — WE'RE NOT RUNNING A BANK HERE. The booths are vinyl. The coffee arrives before you order it. And every single story I've written that anyone actually remembered started somewhere within a few blocks of that room.

For years I thought that was a limitation. I thought the material was elsewhere — the bigger city, the more interesting coast, the setting with more obvious drama. I spent a lot of energy reaching for a room I'd never been in instead of describing the one I knew down to the way the screen door caught on the frame in July.

I was wrong about all of it.

The Stoplight as a Unit of Measurement

I grew up in a place you describe by subtraction. No traffic. No airport. No reason to stop unless you lived there. When people ask where I'm from, I used to round up to the nearest city with a recognizable name, which is a kind of lying that catches up with you.

The rounding-up instinct is the whole problem. It assumes that specificity is a local flavor — nice for the people who were there, irrelevant to everyone else. The opposite is true. Specificity is the mechanism by which a person in Ohio recognizes a feeling they had in a completely different state. The detail isn't decoration on top of the universal thing. The detail is how the universal thing travels.

Polish Is a Form of Hiding

When I tried to write "for everyone," I wrote vague. Vague settings. Vague people. Vague problems that could have happened anywhere, which meant they landed nowhere. I stripped out the family shorthand, the regional words, the exact smell of a place, because I thought that stuff was clutter between the reader and the meaning.

It was the only meaning I had.

There's a specific fear underneath the polish, and it's a small one: if I'm too specific, they'll know I'm from somewhere unimpressive. So you sand it down. You write a story set in Anytown, USA, and it reads like a stock photo of a story. Technically competent. Utterly weightless.

An Inventory of the Unremarkable

Here's the exercise I now run when I'm stuck, and I'd suggest it before you go looking for a more interesting place to set anything.

List the nouns of your childhood. Not the themes. The nouns. The brand of bread. The name of the road that floods. The nickname nobody outside the family would understand. The exact sound the screen door makes.

Write the rules of a room. Every place has unwritten laws. At that diner, you didn't sit in the corner booth after 8 a.m. because it belonged to three retired men and everyone knew it. That's not a charming detail — that's a whole essay about territory and belonging, sitting there in plain sight.

Collect the phrases. Family shorthand is compressed storytelling. Mine has a phrase meaning we're not talking about it that's four words long and forty years old. Every family has three of these. Write them down before they go extinct.

Name the thing you're embarrassed by. The town's annual event that everyone mocks. The building that's been "about to be renovated" since 1998. Shame is a material source with a surprisingly long shelf life.

The Three-Question Test

Once you have a pile of these details, you need a way to know which ones are load-bearing. I ask three questions.

Does it cost me something to include it? If the detail makes me look small, provincial, or tender, it's probably working.

Would someone who wasn't there still picture it? Not understand it — picture it. If the answer is no, it may be too private rather than too specific.

Does it do a job? A good local detail isn't a museum exhibit. It should put pressure on the story — reveal a power dynamic, a history, a want. The corner booth isn't scenery. It's a hierarchy.

Don't Upgrade the Setting

The instinct, when a story isn't working, is to move it somewhere more impressive. A bigger city. A fancier room. A job title with more syllables. I've done this, and what happens is that you inherit all the same problems plus a set of new ones, because you don't actually know how the screen door catches in that town.

You already have the material. It's boring to you because you lived it. That's the tax. But it's also the reason nobody else can write it.

The diner still doesn't have a website. The sign by the register is still there, slightly more faded. I've written about that room maybe six times now, and I'm not close to done, because every time I go back I notice a different rule I never thought to question.

All Articles

Related Articles

17,000 Photos and the Truth Nobody Posts: An Audit of My Own Camera Roll

17,000 Photos and the Truth Nobody Posts: An Audit of My Own Camera Roll

Sixty Seconds at the Counter: The Stranger Who Decides Which Ideas Get Made

Sixty Seconds at the Counter: The Stranger Who Decides Which Ideas Get Made

The Exit Music: Why I Walked Away From the Only Thing Everyone Wanted Me to Keep Doing

The Exit Music: Why I Walked Away From the Only Thing Everyone Wanted Me to Keep Doing